Steel Roof vs. Asphalt Roof: Which Is Better for Your Iowa Home?

If you’re replacing your roof in Iowa, one of the biggest questions is whether to choose a steel roof or a traditional asphalt shingle roof. Both can be great options, but the right choice depends on your budget, long-term plans, and how much durability you want.

Here’s a simple breakdown.

Steel Roof vs. Asphalt Roof: Quick Answer

• Choose steel if you want maximum lifespan, stronger weather resistance, and lower long-term maintenance.

• Choose asphalt if you want the lower upfront cost and a widely used, reliable roofing option.

Steel vs Asphalt Roofs

Pros & Cons of Steel Roofs

Pros

• Long lifespan (often decades longer than asphalt)

• Excellent wind resistance

• Strong performance in snow and rain

• Lower maintenance over time

• Energy-efficient reflective options are available

Cons

• Higher upfront cost

• Installation requires specialized experience

• Can be noisier during heavy rain without proper attic insulation

• Cosmetic dents may happen from hail, depending on the product type

Pros & Cons of Asphalt (Shingle) Roofs

Pros

• Lower initial cost

• Many color and style choices

• Faster installation

• Easy to repair or replace sections

• Common choice for most homes

Cons

• Shorter lifespan than steel

• Can be damaged by hail or high winds

• May require replacement sooner

• Granule loss and aging over time

What’s the Cost Difference?

Costs vary by roof size, slope, material type, and labor, but in general:

• Asphalt roofs usually have a lower upfront price

• Steel roofs usually cost more initially, but may last much longer

That means asphalt can be more affordable today, while steel may offer better long-term value.

The best way to compare is to look at the lifetime cost, not just the installation price.

Insurance: Steel Roof vs. Asphalt Roof

Insurance coverage depends on your carrier, policy, roof age, and damage cause, but here are common trends:

Asphalt Roofs

• Standard and widely accepted by insurers

• Older roofs may receive reduced coverage or ACV-only settlement

• Damage from hail/wind is a common claim type

Steel Roofs

• Some insurers view steel favorably because of its durability and fire resistance

• You may qualify for discounts with some carriers

• Cosmetic hail dents may be treated differently from functional damage, depending on the policy

Always ask your insurance provider:

• Is coverage based on ACV or RCV?

• Are cosmetic dents covered on metal roofs?

• Is there a premium discount for impact-resistant materials?

• Does roof age affect claim settlement?

Which Roof Is Best in Iowa?

With Iowa weather bringing hail, wind, snow, and temperature swings, deciding between a Steel Roof vs. Asphalt Roof is important.

• Asphalt is a practical, budget-friendly choice

• Steel is a premium durability choice with long-term benefits

There is no one-size-fits-all answer—only the best fit for your home and budget.

Final Takeaway

If you plan to stay in your home long-term and want durability, steel may be worth the investment. If you want a lower upfront cost and proven performance, asphalt remains a strong option.

A trusted local roofer (Rod White) can inspect your home, explain material options, and provide side-by-side pricing for your specific property.

Contact our team today.   Rod White - (319) 217-0392

Also, if you refer a friend, family member, or neighbor, we'll pay you a referral fee!!